Kat Candler’s Retribution (formerly known as Hellion) boasts some strong performances but ultimately feels like an amalgamation of various indie tropes that never quite hit the right emotional spot.
Texas-set Retribution follows widowed single father Hollis (Aaron Paul) who finds himself on the verge of losing his two sons to Child Protection Services after eldest son Jacob’s (Josh Wiggins) unruly behaviour attracts the attention of the police.
It seems that films revelling in Southern miserablism are all the rage recently with Mud, Joe and The Devil’s Knot all looking at the hard lives of the vulnerable people in the South of the USA. Perhaps the reason I draw this comparison is because Hellion shares so much in common with these films (and they are just the first few that come to mind), with the narrative for Candler’s film instantly feeling familiar. The rebellious young teen son acting out against his struggling (or alternatively, irresponsible) parent and getting into trouble with the law has become somewhat of a staple in the coming of age indie melodrama.
Whilst in itself this familiarity is not a bad thing, Retribution feels incredibly forced and staged in its portrait of rebellious teen adolescence and familial struggling – so much so that it is a challenge to connect to on an emotional level. Scenes like Jacob doing motocross (consistently set to an overbearing heavy metal soundtrack), causing a scene at a local diner, a botched home invasion, and ultimately a midnight ferry ride feel too contrived for the film’s own good. Retribution fares better when capturing the family in its more intimate moments: there is a certain sweetness in Hollis’s relationship with youngest son Wes (Deke Garner) and poignant scenes where Hollis visits the site of his wife’s accident. These low-key moments succeed as they simply are not trying too hard to make us feel something.
A strong performance from Aaron Paul proves to be his most mature and dramatically challenging yet – with the star hitting one of the few emotional nerves in the film as struggling father Hollis. Josh Wiggins and Deke Garner also showcase themselves as strong talents both with an impressive range and convincing authenticity in their roles. A supporting role for Juliette Lewis also completes the cast with the actress shining as Hollis’s sister-in-law who is caught between wanting the best for her nephews and respecting her brother-in-law by not interfering.
There are a few quiet moments when the emotion in Retribution is raw and somewhat powerful, but it ultimately loses strength in contrived melodramatic scenes, despite impressive performances from a talented cast.
Genre:Drama, Thriller Distributor: Signature Entertainment DVD Release Date: 5th January 2015 (UK)Rating: 15 Running Time: 94 Minutes Director:Cat Candler Cast:Aaron Paul, Juliette Lewis, Josh Wiggins, Deke Garner
*The is a reprint of Edinburgh Film Festival Review under Hellion name.